Capital Preservation Analysis • FindMyLifePlan
Fixed Index Annuity vs Bank CD: Which Protects Capital Better?
Comparing Fixed Index & MYGA Annuities vs Bank Certificates of Deposit (CDs). Learn about yield spreads, tax-deferral advantages, and liquidity.
Advisor Verdict: Annuity Wins for Long-Term Retirement Capital
| Key Decision Factor | Option A (Annuity) | Option B (CD) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Yield Potential | 5.5% - 7.5% (Fixed / Index Cap) | 4.0% - 5.0% (Short-term peak) |
| Tax Treatment of Interest | Tax-Deferred until withdrawn | Taxed annually on 1099-INT |
| Lifetime Income Option | Yes, guaranteed lifetime paycheck | No, principal dissolves when spent |
| Guaranty Protection | State Guaranty Associations ($300k-$500k) | FDIC Insured ($250k per depositor) |
| Upfront Bonuses | Up to 10% - 15% instant bonus | 0% Bonus |
Independent Actuarial Summary
Annuities generally deliver 1.0% to 2.5% higher annual yields with tax-deferred compounding and lifetime income riders, whereas CDs offer shorter maturities (6-12 months).